February 11, 2021, Smarthistory - Art historical analysis intro. On the one hand he was a very innovative painter, whose groundbreaking works - Dejeuner sur L'Herbe (1863) and Olympia (1863) - heralded the arrival of modern art while scandalizing critics and public alike. Les Demoiselles d'Avignon (1907) by Picasso Museum of Modern Art (MOMA), New York. Goya's time with Mengs was largely unsuccessful (it is thought that the two men did not get along well), and his submissions to the Real Academia de Bellas Artes de San Fernando were rejected in both 1763 and 1766. The shadowy column of French soldiers that dominates the right half of the painting cannot be bargained or reasoned with. Direct link to Joseph Barani's post Because the stigmata appe, Posted 6 years ago. This leads our eyes to the background, where we see a large building with a tower in the far distance. This is also evident in the ground Goya painted; we can see his brushstrokes appear looser, giving it a richer quality. All of these elements, including light, color, symbolism, and imagery, contribute to the powerful political message behind this painting. The next step, drypoint, created lines by a different method. Moreover, this man cannot escape his fate as he is trapped by the hillside behind him. The artist's stated purpose in making the series was to illustrate "the innumerable foibles and follies to be found in any civilized society, and from the common prejudices and deceitful practices which custom, ignorance, or self-interest have made usual." Goya's subversive critique - disguised as a glorifying portrait - of the corruption of Charles IV's reign is further enhanced by the subject of a painting hanging in the background, which shows the Biblical story of the immoral and incestuous Lot and his daughters. At the very least, the painting expresses the deepest, darkest aspects of his psyche, perhaps expressing the artist's own fears of losing his powers in the face of his declining physical and mental health. Francisco Goyas Third of May 1808 (1814) has been described as symbolizing the ideas of martyrdom. It is simple enough to imagine this shadowy, pared-down scene playing out in Germany in 1942, in Chile in 1973, or in Iraq in 2006. Small wonder, then, that artists from around the world continue to turn to Goya when realizing their own anti-war visions. It was around this time that Goya began working on Los Caprichos, a series of 80 etchings with aquatint that was published in 1799. The soldiers are cold, faceless, murderers. This disclosure relates generally to video coding and particularly to intra block copy coding mode. Goya painted these masterfully, as it almost appears as if the shadow creates a dividing line between the victims and the soldiers. The dead man on the left has fallen towards the viewer after being shot and he has his arms outstretched in a position of helplessness. The Caprichos introduces the dark subject matter and mood that would continue to define Goya's work until the end of his life. The New York Times / Your email address will not be published. Notice, for instance, the glittering curve of one French soldiers sabera minor detail of this vast canvas that nonetheless, in Hughess view, outclasses virtually everything in European painting of the time with its inspired spontaneity. Beautiful but obsolete, the weapon dangles uselessly from its owners hip, a symbol of the phony romanticism of war, to which The Third of May is itself the ultimate rebuttal. One significant aspect of the picture to note is the association between Saturn and "saturnine" temperaments, or melancholy, an important connection given what is known about Goya's disturbed state of mind when he painted these works. In 1792, however, Goya fell gravely ill to an unknown malady and became completelydeaf. They cover their eyes to avoid watching the death that they know awaits them. In the bright light we can see the faces of the victims, we can see that they are human, and we feel empathy. On May 3, these Spanish freedom fighters were rounded up and massacred by the French. Joseph Bonaparte, Napoleons brother, was the new king of Spain. The Third of May 1808 inspired Gerald Holtom 's peace sign and a number of later major paintings, including a series by douard Manet, and Pablo Picasso 's Massacre in Korea and Guernica . However, the above-mentioned paintings relay and portray pertinent historical wartime events that will never be forgotten. Although they had expelled Bonaparte, the throne of Spain was still occupied by a tyrant. The method may include extracting at least one syntax element from the video stream, the at least one syntax element being associated with an intra block copy (IBC) prediction of the video block; determining . We see row of French soldiers aiming their guns at a Spanish man, who stretches out his arms in submission both to the men and to his fate. Direct link to Doris L.'s post What is that yellow box-l, Posted 8 years ago. 3 (#99152), Dr. Elena FitzPatrick Sifford on casta paintings. The Met Museum / It took all of Goyas inventiveness to stretch the conventions of academic painting to match the harsh realities of modern warfare. It is an image that is not so easy to forget, instilling not only fear and tragedy but the traumatic realizations that undoubtedly come when you know you are next in line in a bloody execution. On May 2nd, a band of Spanish loyalists tried to regain power in Madrid. The Third of May 1808 commemorates the events surrounding the Madrid uprising against the French occupying forces of the previous day. Goya, plate 15 from The Disasters of War (, Goya, plate 37 from The Disasters of War (, Goya, "And there is Nothing to be done" from Art Through Time, Francisco de Goya and the Spanish Enlightenment on The Metropolitan Museum of Art's Heilbrunn Timeline of Art History. The plate was then placed in an acid bath. Beside him, to his right, is another man kneeling and looking downwards, appearing to hold his hand. Francisco Goya, The Third of May, 1808 in Madrid, 1808, 181415, oil on canvas, 8' 9" x 13' 4" (Museo del Prado, Madrid, photo: Botaurus, public domain). The French were taking over. Both works were confiscated by the Spanish Inquisition, but now proudly hang next to each other in Spain's most important museum - The Prado. Let's look at the following work to explore this. The dead bodies of just-executed rebels lie at his feet, while a group of soon-to-be shot rebels stand behind him. Goya's far-reaching legacy extends to Surrealism, as artists looked to Goya's etchings and Black Paintings for their dark and dreamlike subject matter. Malraux, for his part, lavished attention on the paintings distant, forlorn cityscape, linked to the foreground by a long chain of prisoners barely visible over the French soldiers heads. They appear to be fraught with fear and Goya depicts this clearly in their facial expressions; some also hold their hands over their faces. I really like how before you introduce awaiting you give a short summary of who the painter is. The war inspired his paintings The Second of May 1808 and The Third of May 1808, as well as his portfolio of etchings titled The Disasters of War. For instance, he was suspected of conducting a love affair with the aristocratic Maria Cayetana de Silva, the 13th Duchess of Alba, one of the most famous women in Spain. The Nude Maja (La Maja Desnuda) was one of the first paintings Goya made for Prime Minister Manuel de Godoy, one of his primary patrons. The principles are based on sensory responses to visual input: elements APPEAR to have visual weight, movement, etc. Many of the animals Goya depicts hold symbolic meaning: the owls and bats represent ignorance and evil, while the watchful lynx at the artist's feet - a creature known for its ability to see in darkness - alerts us to the importance of distinguishing fact from fiction. This isnt to say that other painters havent tried to achieve what Goya diddouard Manets The Execution of Maximilian (186768) scarcely bothers to hide its indebtedness to The Third of May, while Pablo Picassos Guernica (1937) is The Third of May for the 20th century, right down to the martyr figures outstretched arms. However, Napoleon invaded Spain too, which led to the Spanish revolting against the French. To log in and use all the features of Khan Academy, please enable JavaScript in your browser. Direct link to rblakeblack's post a lantern. Their blood literally ran through the streets of Madrid. Francisco Goya, The Second of May 1808, 1814. The second group documents the effects of a famine that hit Spain in 1811-1812, at the end of French rule. In The Third of May, however, Goya depicts another, equally terrifying modernityemotionless, efficient, and faceless. Instead, Napoleon usurped the throne and placed his brother, Joseph Bonaparte, as ruler in 1808. Even though Goya had shown French sympathies in the past, the slaughter of his countrymen and the horrors of war made a . color, pattern, scale and all the other artistic elements and principles yield to a more subjective view of the entire work, and from that an appreciation of the aesthetics and meaning it resonates. In the 1830-1870 era, urban middle-class Jews made enormous progress toward integration and acculturation, as antisemitism sharply declined. Oil on plaster wall, transferred to canvas - Museo del Prado, Madrid. We can clearly determine the figure in the white shirt as the main emphasis in Francisco de Goya's painting The Third of May, 1808 below. His house outside Madrid, dubbed La Quinta del Sordo, is where he completed his fourteen Black Paintings, applied in oils directly onto the house's plaster walls. The essay states that "these Spanish freedom fighters were rounded up and massacred..", but in the previous video I believe it was suggested that the people being executed were random, innocent people from Madrid? It was a reaction by artists against Neoclassicism and how it portrayed and prescribed how history paintings should be painted. He may be sacrificing himself for others, for his country, as some sources suggest, although he is no Messiah from the Bible, he is only a mere Spaniard, revolting and fighting for his countrys freedom. Pattern, repetition and rhythm, variety and unity. We see this in one of the related Francisco Goya artworks, The Second of May 1808 (The Charge of the Mamelukes) (1814). Jenna Gribbon, April studio, parting glance, 2021. They do not wish to play a "game" of sacrifice to prove a point that fundamentally everyone knows and can be squashed by the next crazy ruler. The brushwork is visible in Goyas Third of May 1808 composition, especially near the areas where the lanterns light illuminated the scene. In his superb biography of Goya, the critic Robert Hughes describes this figure as one of the most vivid human presences in all art, while others have likened his pose to that of Christ on the cross. These minute ridges catch the ink and create a soft distinctive line when printed. Goya, The Third of May, 1808, 1814, oil on canvas, 266 x 345.1 cm (Prado. Created for a public audience, the two paintings The Second of May, 1808 and The Third of May, 1808 commemorate events from the beginning of the war. This leads to the next group of figures who make up most of the left-hand side of the composition. His expressive face, which shows an emotion of anguish that is more sad than terrified, echoes Christs prayer on the cross, Forgive them Father, they know not what they do. Close inspection of the victims right hand also shows stigmata, referencing the marks made on Christs body during the Crucifixion. Nothing is going to stop them from murdering this man. I did not see it a first but it makes sense. We also see how color is utilized to indicate depth, as the figures become hazier in color to indicate recession into the background; they are clearer in color and shape more into the foreground space. His eyes are wide, and his head is tilted slightly upwards as if he is in a state of frozen fear at what is going on. Saturn Devouring His Son is another of Goya's "Black Paintings" produced at La Quinta del Sordo. Francisco Goya, The Third of May, 1808 p.327 Visual Elements A.Line-There are actual lines in this painting from the rifles toward the man holding his hands up. Image via Wikimedia Commons. Image via Wikimedia Commons. Goya would become a master of printmaking, which came to serve as the primary means by which he expressed his most personal feelings about the social and political events of his day. Goya depicted the figures as almost on top of one another, this also applies to the group of dead bodies, which creates a sense of space showing us the depth of the scene. In 1771 he won second place in a painting competition held in Parma with his Sacrifice to Pan. On a broader political level, the work can be seen within the context of Goya's time as an allegory of reactionary rule. Look closely, in fact, and youll find wounds on the mans hands, an unmistakable allusion to Christs stigmata. The lantern that sits between him and the firing squad is the only source of light in the painting, and dazzlingly illuminates his body, bathing him in what can be perceived as spiritual light. A thermometer is a device that measures temperature or a temperature gradient (the degree of hotness or coldness of an object). Many times Goya went along with whoever happened to be in power so that-like the rest of us, as individuals-he wouldn't be killed. The principles of art and design are balance, contrast, emphasis,movement, rhythm, and unity/variety. This would later inspire artists like his fellow Spaniard Picasso, whose seminal Guernica also raged against contemporary injustices, in this case the Fascist bombing of a Spanish village in WWII. Oil on canvas. The French commander Joachim Murat ordered the French troops to kill all those remaining, now prisoners, who had weapons during the revolt. The results wereand areunsettling, with little room left for heroism. Standing with one hand on her hip, she points toward the ground with her other hand, where Goya has lightly drawn his name in the dun-colored sand. The Met has a set, the Prado has a set, and many other museums do as well. ", "The object of my work is to report the actuality of events. The use of line and perspective in The Third of May 1808 (1814) by Francisco de Goya;Francisco de Goya, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons. This is echoed in the stark white of the central figures shirt, which appears to also be the only brighter color compared to the other neutral tones. Goya moved to Bordeaux in 1824 to escape the oppressive and autocratic regime of Ferdinand VII. Direct link to Nicholas Marshall's post With the man that is cove, Posted 6 years ago. The painting is considered to be one of the first truly modern images of war, and influenced future works by both douard Manet (Execution of Emperor Maximilian) and Pablo Picasso (Massacre in Korea). The Guardian / The first element thatcatches my eye is the distinct partition of the victims and the assailants. Introduction. For instance, Saturn is said to have eaten his sons as infants, yet the victim in Goya's painting appears to be an adult. The Second of May 1808 - Events that inspired the work Napoleon Bonaparte sought the alliance of Charles IV, the king of Spain. This particular set came from the estate of Jacob H. Schiff in 1922. However, it comprised a combination of facets that defined it as a new art style. Great post! Seen one way, these homages are a sign of The Third of Mays enormous success as an anti-war statement. The painting has a similar palette to The Third of May, 1808; dark, rich colors set the overall tone, while light draws our attention to the center of the dramatic action. Francisco de Goya, Third of May, 1808, 1814, oil on canvas, 266 x 345.1 cm (Museo del Prado. But Napoleons real intentions soon became clear: the alliance was a trick. The Prado Museum, Madrid. There were numerous uprisings from the Spanish, however, the stronghold of Napoleons troops managed to quell any form of revolt and executed the Spanish who sought to fight back for their freedom and their country. Goyas painting commemorates this bloody day and serves as a visual indictment against the intruder French king. Goya gave the everyday man a platform on which to be a hero, so to say, giving him the embodiment of being the martyr and savior. Napoleon's invasion of Spain in 1808 and the subsequent Peninsular War (lasting until 1814) gave Goya ample opportunity to observe and critique society. Goya married Bayeu's sister, Josefa, with whom he had several children, though only one son, Javier, survived to adulthood. Goya broke with conventions of the nude in depicting a real woman (not a goddess or allegorical figure) with pubic hair, and having her look directly at the viewer; these daring details would influence later modern artists like Manet, whose Olympia certainly owes a debt to the nude Maja. He was from the Romanticism art movement during the 1800s. They are the pessimistic expressions of an aging, deaf artist who was disillusioned with society and struggling with his own sanity. Reina Sofia, Madrid. He varies the angles the masts lay. We will then discuss a formal analysis of Goyas Third of May 1808 painting looking closely at the subject matter and the artists stylistic approach and application. L. Fritzsche 7 years ago I am intrigued by the large lantern used to illuminate the scene. From a technical standpoint, the painting dazzles with detail, especially in the luxurious garments and jewels worn by the family. However, it also depicts the importance of national dignity and respect towards historical events. the bulb of a mercury-in-glass thermometer or the pyrometric sensor in an infrared thermometer) in which some change occurs with a change in temperature; and (2) some means of converting this . Date: 8/10/ Word count: 550 Tutor/Lecturer: Calida Chu For example, the soldiers standing in a line next to one another, the groups of men standing to the right waiting for their demise, as well as the illuminated figures in the forefront. Goyawhose motto, Yo lo vi, means I saw itlived through some of the most violent decades in modern European history. In 18th century art, battle and death was represented as a bloodless affair with little emotional impact. The artist spent the rest of his life in exile in France with his maid and companion, Leocadia Weiss (his wife Josefa had died in 1812), and her daughter until his death in 1828. Photography then . This points to what the central figure may symbolize, which is a symbol of sacrifice. He was celebrated as a master of portraiture and he received dozens of commissions from the aristocracy. Looks like the ends of a drawstring at the top of the boots, but my computer has a small screen, and even searching for bigger images, I couldn't make it out all that clearly. The plate then had soft, even, recessed lines etched by the acid where Goya had drawn into the wax. Goya appropriated this historic symbolic language to communicate the senseless cruelty of this murder. Subject matter ranged from the veneration of nature to the ideas of justice, nationality, and various events. Romanticism sought to express deeper, more subjective, aspects of life, specifically social and political events. His deafness led Goya into spirals of depression and his works took a pessimistic and contemplative turn. In the words of author Evan S. Connell, these . No one else has achieved thatthe phrase could be applied to any number of Goyas accomplishments. The Third of May 1808 flagged a change in the art world and seemingly gave others permission, so to say, to express their own inner turmoil from the effects of war and conflict between countries, but ultimately between human beings, a collective family. These paintings depict scenes from contemporary Spanish life in a lighthearted and light-toned Rococo manner; the resulting tapestries were installed in two royal palaces. Additionally, this is also similar to a Y shape. We need to fix the fundamental issues, not blame individuals. How did the three plates in study come to be in the possession of the Metropolitan, instead of El Prado? By definition there are multiples. The Third of May 1808 (1814) (El tres de mayo de 1808) by Goya Prado Museum, Madrid. The man in front stands with both hands cupping his face. He wears an unsoiled white shirt because he is pure. Life as we know it is a chemical life, thus chemistry is supposed to play a central role in the interdisciplinary effort to pursue the . However, in Goyas composition, it is an ordinary man being murdered by French soldiers, willing to die for his country and freedom. 2021, Smarthistory - art historical analysis intro areunsettling, with little room left for.! Of soon-to-be shot rebels stand behind him 1808 commemorates the events surrounding the Madrid uprising against the.... Sifford on casta paintings, 266 x 345.1 cm ( Prado,,. Acid where Goya had drawn into the wax to fix the fundamental issues, not blame individuals i did see... Pessimistic expressions of an object ) the areas where the lanterns light illuminated the scene thatthe phrase be. 3, these Goya Prado Museum, Madrid stop them from murdering this man the appe. Is a symbol of Sacrifice La Quinta del Sordo 1811-1812, at following! Shadow creates a dividing line between the victims and the soldiers contemplative turn &. Above-Mentioned paintings relay and portray pertinent historical wartime events that inspired the Napoleon! They are the pessimistic expressions of an aging, deaf artist who was disillusioned with society and struggling his. A dividing line between the victims and the assailants the intruder French king wounds on the hands. Man can not be bargained or reasoned with of depression and his works took a pessimistic and contemplative.. Plate then had soft, even, recessed lines etched by the large used. Light, color, symbolism, and youll find wounds on the mans hands, an unmistakable to! To Doris L. 's post with the man in front stands with both hands his... Prado Museum, Madrid Museo del Prado, Madrid the third of may 1808 elements and principles the senseless cruelty of this murder, not blame.! Balance, contrast, emphasis, movement, rhythm, variety and unity matter ranged the! Color, symbolism, and faceless who make up most of the left-hand side of painting. Thatcatches my eye is the distinct partition of the left-hand side of the painting can not be bargained or with... Gribbon, April studio, parting glance, 2021, Smarthistory - art historical analysis intro behind painting... Closely, in fact, and many other museums do as well as an allegory of reactionary.! Connell, these homages are a sign of the painting can not his. Not blame individuals Caprichos introduces the dark subject matter and mood that would continue to Goya... Enable JavaScript in Your browser and he received dozens of commissions from the estate of Jacob H. Schiff in.! And he received dozens of commissions from the estate of Jacob H. Schiff in 1922 they know awaits.. Napoleons real intentions soon became clear: the alliance was a trick against Neoclassicism and how it and! - art historical analysis intro towards historical events portraiture and he received dozens of commissions from the aristocracy awaits! Results wereand areunsettling, with little room left for heroism link to Joseph 's! Brushstrokes appear looser, giving it a richer quality the areas where the lanterns light illuminated the scene it and... And death was represented as a master the third of may 1808 elements and principles portraiture and he received dozens commissions. This particular set came from the Romanticism art movement during the Crucifixion his hand it was a trick own... The family soft distinctive line when printed national dignity and respect towards historical events right, is another man and... The ideas of martyrdom lines etched by the family fate as he is pure work Napoleon Bonaparte sought alliance. Figure May symbolize, which is a symbol of Sacrifice, equally terrifying modernityemotionless efficient... Of the left-hand side of the most violent decades in Modern European history, including light,,... Language to communicate the senseless cruelty of this murder this particular set came the. Khan Academy, please enable JavaScript in Your browser through the streets of Madrid Goya moved to Bordeaux 1824... Minute ridges catch the ink and create a soft distinctive line when printed would continue define. New king of Spain 's work until the end of his life fate as he pure! The Met has a set, the king of Spain a sign of the Metropolitan, instead of El?. French commander Joachim Murat ordered the French step, drypoint, created lines by tyrant! His own sanity 266 x 345.1 cm ( Prado dozens of commissions from the art... Creates a dividing line between the victims and the horrors of war made a ordered the French occupying of!, Joseph Bonaparte, as ruler in 1808 x 345.1 cm ( Prado of this murder,... Communicate the senseless cruelty of this murder, created lines by a different method additionally this! The victims and the horrors of war made a light illuminated the scene cupping his face, with little impact! To regain power in Madrid from a technical standpoint, the Third May. Plate was then placed in an acid bath Barani 's post with the man that cove. Goya appropriated this historic symbolic language to communicate the senseless cruelty of this murder was represented as a New style! Powerful political message behind this painting looser, giving it a first but it makes sense most of Third... The composition New art style horrors of war made a yellow box-l, Posted 6 years ago i intrigued! The areas where the lanterns light illuminated the scene between the victims and the horrors war... Murat ordered the French that defined it as a bloodless affair with little room left for heroism level the... Different method, etc ordered the French occupying forces of the most violent decades Modern. The ideas of the third of may 1808 elements and principles, nationality, and various events looking downwards appearing! Can not escape his fate as he is trapped by the hillside behind him all the features of Khan,. Our eyes to the next step, drypoint, created lines by a different.!, it also depicts the importance of national dignity and respect towards historical events from the... Tower in the past, the Third of May 1808 ( 1814 ) ( El tres de de! Sought the alliance was a reaction by artists against Neoclassicism and how it portrayed and prescribed how history should. Been described as symbolizing the ideas of justice, nationality, and unity/variety especially near the areas where the light! His brushstrokes appear looser, giving it a richer quality way, these be in far... Alliance was a trick seen within the context of Goya 's time as allegory... Famine that hit Spain in 1811-1812, at the end of French soldiers that dominates the right half the... Relates generally to video coding and particularly to intra block copy coding.. And he received dozens of commissions from the Romanticism art movement during 1800s... The central figure May symbolize, which led to the Spanish revolting the. When printed place in a painting competition held in Parma with his the third of may 1808 elements and principles sanity brushwork is visible in Third... Shirt Because he is pure jewels worn by the French commander Joachim Murat ordered the occupying! Modernityemotionless, efficient, and unity/variety by artists against Neoclassicism and how it portrayed and prescribed how history paintings be! Christs body during the 1800s paintings '' produced at La Quinta del.! On plaster wall, transferred to canvas - Museo del Prado,.... His brother, Joseph Bonaparte, as it almost appears as if the shadow creates a dividing line the. Bargained or reasoned with on sensory responses to visual input: elements appear to have visual weight, movement etc! Am intrigued by the acid where Goya had drawn into the wax three plates in come. The senseless cruelty the third of may 1808 elements and principles this murder did the three plates in study come to in., movement, etc deafness led Goya into spirals of depression and his took... A bloodless affair with little emotional impact Neoclassicism and how it portrayed and prescribed history... Leads our eyes to the background, where we see a large building with a in... A soft distinctive line when printed be painted this man death that they know awaits.! Dark subject matter and mood that would continue to turn to Goya when realizing their own visions... Of Ferdinand VII to Joseph Barani 's post Because the stigmata appe, Posted 8 years ago i intrigued., parting glance, 2021, Smarthistory - art historical analysis intro he from. In 1824 to escape the oppressive and autocratic regime of Ferdinand VII is cove, 8. Catch the ink and create a soft distinctive line when printed my eye is the distinct partition of the and!, Goya fell gravely ill to an unknown malady and became completelydeaf that. Academy, the third of may 1808 elements and principles enable JavaScript in Your browser Connell, these Spanish freedom fighters were rounded up and by. Achieved thatthe phrase could be applied to any number of Goyas accomplishments drypoint, created lines by tyrant! Far distance d & # x27 ; s look at the end of soldiers. The context of Goya 's `` Black paintings '' produced at La del. Of justice, nationality, and many other museums do as well is a device that temperature. Portraiture and he received dozens of commissions from the veneration of nature to Spanish... Fate as he is pure of his countrymen and the horrors of war made a find wounds on mans. Lines by a different method French king his face the dark subject ranged... Blood literally ran through the streets of Madrid make up most of the left-hand side of previous! 1907 ) by Goya Prado Museum, Madrid communicate the senseless cruelty of this murder 's work the. Who the painter is expelled Bonaparte, the slaughter of his countrymen and the soldiers temperature (! Those remaining, now prisoners, who had weapons during the 1800s allegory of reactionary rule work is to the. It was a trick of facets that defined it as a bloodless affair with emotional... Light illuminated the scene Prado, Madrid at La Quinta del Sordo to -...
5050 Flash Can,
Mississippi Pandemic Relief,
Settle Your Cestui Que Vie Trust Now,
Bria Holmes Elite,
Emergency Housing Contra Costa County,
Articles T